BENEFIT OF CLERGY
benefit of clergy. 1. At common law, the privilege of a cleric not to be tried for a felony in the King’s Court <in the Middle Ages, any man who could recite the “neck verse” was granted the benefit of clergy>. • Although clergy includes monks and nuns as well as priests, there are no known cases of women claiming or being granted benefit of clergy. Congress outlawed benefit of clergy in federal courts in April 1790. It was abolished in England in 1827 but survived even longer in some American states, such as South Carolina, where it was successfully claimed in 1855. State v. Bosse, 42 S.C.L. (3 Rich.) 276 (1855). — Also termed clergy privilege; clericale privilegium. See NECK VERSE.
“Benefit of clergy was a remarkable privilege which, although now obsolete, was for centuries of great importance in criminal law. Some knowledge of it is even now essential for a proper understanding of common law crimes. After William the Conqueror separated the ecclesiastical from the secular courts, the clergy put forward the claim that all persons in holy orders should be exempt from secular jurisdiction in all proceedings, civil or criminal. Eventually the rule was established that ‘clerks’ of all kinds, who committed any of the serious crimes termed felonies, could be tried only in an ecclesiastical court, and therefore were only amenable to such punishments as that court could inflict. Any clerk accused of such crime was accordingly passed over to the bishop’s court. He was there tried before a jury of clerks by the oaths of twelve compurgators; a mode of trial which usually ensured him an acquittal.” J.W. Cecil Turner, Kenny’s Outlines of Criminal Law 75 (16th ed. 1952).
“ ‘Benefit of clergy,’ in its origin, was the right of a clergyman not to be tried for felony in the King’s Court. In ancient times, when the Church was at the peak point of its power, it preempted jurisdiction over felony charges against clergymen. It demanded that in any case in which a clergyman was charged with felony, the case be transferred to the Ecclesiastical Court for trial. The benefit was extreme because conviction of felony in the King’s Court resulted in the sentence of death, whereas the Ecclesiastical Court did not make use of capital punishment.” Rollin M. Perkins & Ronald N. Boyce, Criminal Law 4 (3d ed. 1982).
- Religious approval as solemnized by church ritual <the couple had several children without benefit of clergy>. • This common use of the phrase is premised on a misunderstanding of its original meaning (sense 1).[Blacks Law 8th]